White Sox Rumors
The trade deadline is only three days away and the name that most Nationals fans have heard discussed most often is 1B Adam Dunn and the team most often linked to Dunn is the Chicago White Sox. Bruce Levine of ESPNChicago.com reported yesterday that
Any deal for Dunn would have to include Daniel Hudson, the White Sox’s top pitching prospect. The Nationals also want one of three White Sox prospects: catcher Tyler Flowers, outfielder Jordan Danks or injured infielder Brent Morel
Who are these four guys?
- RHP Dan Hudson (FutureSox scouting report)- 23-year old, 6’4″ 220-lb starting pitcher was the Whit Sox #3 prospect according to Baseball America’s pre-season rankings. According to BA, his strengths are “Hudson throws three solid pitches from a three-quarters arm slot with a crossfire delivery, a la Jered Weaver. His motion gives him natural deception, making his lively 91-93 mph fastball seem even quicker. His second-best pitch is his changeup, which elicits swings and misses. He also has a low-80s slider with average tilt, and he occasionally throws a slow curve. He pounds the strike zone and commands his fastball to both sides of the plate.” but that is countered with concerns that his delivery can get out of whack. From everything I’ve read, he projects best as a #3 or 4 starter. He was 11-4 with 108K and 31 BB over 93 1/3IP in Triple-A and has been 1-1 with a 6.32 ERA, 14K and 11B in 15 2/3 major league innings in 2010. You can slot him in at #3 or 4 in the Nats current rotation (and higher if Strasburg is out for any extended time).
- CA Tyler Flowers (FutureSox scouting report)- 24-year old, 6’4″ 220-lb right-handed catcher. Flowers was ranked as the Sox #2 overall pre-season prospect by BA. Their description of his strengths, “Flowers combines light-tower power with plate discipline, making it easy to project his bat into the middle of a big league lineup. He generates his pop through his strength and size, and he has good hand-eye coordination and advanced pitch recognition. Pitchers like throwing to him because he’s a good communicator and works hard on gameplans. Managers rated him the top defensive catcher in the Double-A Southern League last year. He has an average arm and has improved his footwork and release, thowing out 29 percent of basestealers last year.” Thus far in 2010, he is hitting 217/327/453 in 79 games for Triple-A Charlotte with 16 homers and 49 RBI; he’s struck out 104 time and walked 40 times over 276AB. He could immediately replace Wil Nieves as the backup catcher and provide the Nationals a healthy option as #2 for 2011.
- 3B Brent Morel (FutureSox socuting report)- 23-year old, 6’2″ 220-lb right-handed 3B. BA had him as the Sox #4 pre-season prospect. BA’s strengths, “Morel is a manager’s dream, with solid tools, outstanding instincts and a blue-collar work ethic. He’s one of the system’s top pure hitters, making good contact with a compact, line-drive swing. He has excellent pitch recognition and attacks fastballs. He has the power to hit 15 homers per year, and could show more as he matures. He runs well enough for a third baseman and is a good baserunner, but he doesn’t project as a basestealer. He’s a natural third baseman with first-step quickness and a plus arm.” A drawback is his lack of power for a corner IF. He started the season in Double-A where he hit 326/376/440 over 49G and has to date, hit 279/317/402 in Triple-A. Obviously, playing 3B is out of the question, what would be interesting is whether or not Morel could play 2B.
- OF Jordan Danks (FutureSox scouting report) – 6’4″ 210-lb left-handed hitting outfielder. BA had him as the Sox pre-season #5 prospect. BA’s strengths “Danks is an excellent athlete and a hard-nosed player. He’s a natural hitter with good bat speed, gap power, surprising bunting ability and above-average speed. He has the range and instincts to play center field, and he also has a solid-average arm.” He’s battled injuries but could be a solid major league regular center fielder. He is currently listed on the DL, hitting 243/314/377 with 6 homers and 32 RBI in Triple-A. Assuming he’s healthy, he’s a viable option for center in 2011.
I was a big fan of the Gordon Beckham rumors, but also realized there was very little chance of that happening. The White Sox would be crazy to trade their starting 2B for Dunn. The comparison that needs to be made is Dunn versus the potential for two draft picks (this assumes he does not sign an extension).
Hudson and any one of the three above guys is a better return (or more accurately, a known quantity) than the two draft picks they’d receive. The picks we are looking at are likely to be one pick in the #15-30 range (most likely) and one pick in the #31-35 range. If you were to tell me the Nationals could choose from a #4 starting pitcher in the majors and a backup catcher for 2011-2014 or two unknown picks that may develop into something better than that but could also turn into guys that top out in the Sally League, I’ll go with the known quantities.
All that being said, my first preference is extending Dunn for no more than three years. If he isn’t willing to agree to a 3-year deal, I’d strongly consider the offer of Hudson plus one of those three to the unknown of the two draft picks. And the order of preference would be: Flowers, Morel & Danks.
